Warning: file_get_contents() [function.file-get-contents]: URL file-access is disabled in the server configuration in /homepages/12/d83843876/htdocs/newlife/wp-content/themes/supernova-pro/lib/functions/supernova-query.php on line 657

Warning: file_get_contents(http://grant-adamson.me.uk/wp-content/themes/supernova-pro/lib/admin/inc/webfonts.json) [function.file-get-contents]: failed to open stream: no suitable wrapper could be found in /homepages/12/d83843876/htdocs/newlife/wp-content/themes/supernova-pro/lib/functions/supernova-query.php on line 657

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /homepages/12/d83843876/htdocs/newlife/wp-content/themes/supernova-pro/lib/functions/supernova-query.php on line 678
Categories

Wordblog revived

incorporating New Life

In defence of the editorial

Jeff Jarvis, the high priest of what he now calls “networked journalism”, believes the leader column is as “outmoded as the medium”. Being a believer in collaboration, The death of the editorialist, at BuzzMachine is a sort of draft encyclical in which he shares his thoughts before writing his definitive opinion.

If he questioned the need for editorials on the grounds that few people read them I would have said that he had a case. But he misses the point. He complains that leader writers “rarely report”, “work anonymously” and “issue opinions as if from the mountaintop”. Jarvis has misunderstood the role of the leader.

The leader is a statement of the evolving position of the newspaper. It is not a piece of reporting and if the writer was named it would become simply another opinion article.

In the leaders we create a position for the newspaper as a corporate body providing the context within which a range of opinions can be expressed. The editorial page, although it may be little read, provides the cement which holds the rest together. It is the attitude of the the paper: its definition.

This differentiates newspapers from broadcasters and news agencies. I see no reason why the leader should not continue on the web. Newspapers will probably survive in print for longer than many believe and they can take their varied attitudes onto the web.

But Jarvis seems to be on a revolutionary rampage, to destroy the old before the new can be created. This is part of what he says:

News organizations should no longer define themselves by the ink on their paper. And publishers may no longer assume the prerogative of telling us what to think just because they buy that ink by the barrel. Now we all have our barrels of bits.

There I think Jarvis has it. If we remove the common opinion from a newspaper. whether it be on paper of online, all we will be left with is a barrel of bits.

About

View all posts by

POST A COMMENT


No Responses

  1. BuzzMachine » Blog Archive » The death of the editorialist says

    […] Wordblog » Blog Archive » In defence of the editorial Says: September 28th, 2006 at 2:18 am […]

  2. Wordblog » Blog Archive » Moderate, don’t write leaders, Jarvis tells newspapers says

    […] Nearly a month ago when Jeff Jarvis suggested in a post on his Buzzmachine blog headed “The death of the editorialist” that leader writers were not needed in an “age of open media”, I disagreed with him. Today he returns to the subject in his New Media column in Media Guardian. […]

  3. Web 2.0 Newspapers » Jarvis’ ‘Death of the Editorialist’ and the Ghosts Fighting Inside His BuzzMachine says

    […] Finally (for now anyway), Andrew Grant-Adamson says Jarvis missed the point: If he questioned the need for editorials on the grounds that few people read them I would have said that he had a case. But he misses the point. He complains that leader writers “rarely report”, “work anonymously” and “issue opinions as if from the mountaintop”. Jarvis has misunderstood the role of the leader. […]

  4. FJ says

    Jarvis’s incessant attempts at provoking panic among professional journalists are beginning to sound a bit lame, not least because the good man doesn’t practice what he preaches when it comes to interactivity and responding to readers on his own website.